W-2 or 1099? How California Classifies Physicians, NPs, PAs and CRNAs
The form a clinic sends you does not decide whether you are an employee. Two different tests do, one federal and one Californian, and physicians fall under a different California test than nurse practitioners, physician assistants and CRNAs.
The short answer
A Form 1099 or a Form W-2 records how you were paid; it does not decide your status. For federal taxes, the IRS weighs behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship. For California, most workers are presumed to be employees under the ABC test unless the hiring entity proves all three of its conditions. Licensed physicians and surgeons serving a health care entity fall under the older Borello test instead. Nurse practitioners, physician assistants, nurses and CRNAs are not on that exception list, so the ABC test is their starting point.
This guide explains the rules. It is not an opinion on any contract or arrangement. Whether a specific role is employment under California law is a legal question for an employment attorney.
What the label changes for taxes
| Employee (W-2) | Independent contractor (1099) | |
|---|---|---|
| Social Security and Medicare | The employer withholds your share from pay and pays a matching employer share. | You pay both shares as self-employment tax, 15.3% on 92.35% of net earnings, up to the Social Security wage base for that part. |
| Income tax | Withheld from each paycheck based on your Form W-4. | Nothing is withheld; you pay through quarterly estimated payments. |
| California disability insurance | Covered through payroll. | Not covered unless you elect Disability Insurance Elective Coverage with the EDD. |
| Business costs | Depends on the employer's reimbursement policy. | Ordinary and necessary costs of the work are deductible against the 1099 income. |
The first year on a 1099 has its own steps, from the W-9 to quarterly payments; they are on your first 1099 as a California clinician, and the W-2 + 1099 set-aside calculator sizes what to keep from each payment.
The federal test
For federal employment taxes and income tax withholding, the IRS uses the common-law rules. The facts that show how much control and independence there is fall into three categories:
- Behavioral: whether the business controls, or has the right to control, what the worker does and how the work is done.
- Financial: whether the business controls the business side of the job, such as how the worker is paid, whether expenses are reimbursed and who provides tools and supplies.
- Type of relationship: written contracts, employee-type benefits such as a pension plan or insurance, and whether the relationship is expected to continue.
No single fact settles it; the IRS looks at the relationship as a whole.
California's ABC test
Since 2020, California presumes that a person who is paid for labor or services is an employee, unless the hiring entity shows all three of these conditions:
- The individual is free from control and direction, both under the contract and in fact.
- The individual performs work that is outside the usual course of the hiring entity's business.
- The individual has their own independently established business of the same type as the work performed.
For a clinician working for a clinic or hospital group, condition B asks whether the clinical work is outside the usual course of that group's business. Labor Code sections 2776 through 2784 set out exceptions where the older Borello test applies instead, each with its own conditions.
Physicians and surgeons: the Borello test
Labor Code section 2783 lists physicians and surgeons, dentists, podiatrists, psychologists and veterinarians licensed in California. When they perform professional or medical services provided to or by a health care entity, including one organized as a sole proprietorship, partnership or professional corporation, the ABC test does not apply and status is decided under Borello.
Borello does not make a physician an independent contractor by default. It weighs many factors, including whether the hiring entity has the necessary control over the manner and means of the work, but control alone is not decisive. Under Borello, as under the ABC test, the worker is presumed to be an employee and the hiring entity has to prove an independent contractor relationship.
NPs, PAs, nurses and CRNAs
Nurse practitioners, physician assistants, registered nurses and nurse anesthetists are not among the occupations listed in section 2783. For them the ABC test is the starting point, unless another exception in sections 2776 through 2784 fits the specific arrangement. Whether one does is a fact-specific legal question.
When the two tests disagree
California adopted the ABC test for its payroll taxes, replacing the common-law standard the EDD used before. Federal employment taxes still follow the IRS common-law rules. Because the tests ask different questions, the same clinician can be an employee for one and an independent contractor for the other. Each agency applies its own answer to its own taxes.
Getting a determination
- IRS, Form SS-8: either the business or the worker can file it to ask the IRS to determine status for federal employment taxes and income tax withholding. The IRS says a determination may take at least six months.
- EDD, Form DE 1870: a business can ask the EDD for a written determination of a worker's status for California payroll taxes.
- Employment law: for wage, benefit or contract disputes under California law, an employment attorney is the right adviser.
What we do, and what we do not
We do not give legal opinions on whether a role is classified correctly. We handle the tax side under whichever status applies: withholding or estimated payments, the return, retirement contributions, and the effect of a change in status partway through a year. For the estimated payments in a year when income jumps, see the first attending year guide.
Frequently asked questions
Primary sources
- IRS, About Form 1040-ES; IRC 7502(a)
- IRS, Self-employment tax (Social Security and Medicare taxes); IRC 1401(a), (b)(1); IRC 1402(a)(12); IRS, Self-employment tax; IRC 1401(b)(1); IRS, Self-employment tax
- IRS, Independent contractor (self-employed) or employee?; IRS, Independent contractor (self-employed) or employee?, Form SS-8
- IRS Publication 15, Social Security and Medicare taxes; section 9, Federal income tax withholding
- Cal. Unemp. Ins. Code 621(b); Labor Code 2775; EDD, Information Sheet: Employment (DE 231); Cal. Unemp. Ins. Code 621(b)(1)-(3); EDD, DE 231; S.G. Borello & Sons, Inc. v. Dept. of Industrial Relations (1989) 48 Cal.3d 341; EDD, DE 231
- Labor Code 2776-2784; EDD, Information Sheet: Occupations - ABC Test Exception (DE 231O); Labor Code 2783(b); EDD, DE 231O; Labor Code 2783; EDD, DE 231O; Cal. Unemp. Ins. Code 621(b); EDD, DE 231O; IRS, Independent contractor or employee?
- EDD, Form DE 1870
- EDD, Disability Insurance Elective Coverage
- IRC 162(a)
Related Guides
Estimated Taxes in Your First Attending Year (California)
The year a clinician moves from a training salary to attending or 1099 income: how the prior-year safe harbor keeps the penalty away, the April bill it leaves behind, withholding as a substitute for estimates, income that starts mid-year, and California's weighted installments and its rule for incomes of a million dollars or more.
California Business Taxation Guide
California business taxes explained: entity selection, the franchise tax, LLC fees, local taxes, and planning considerations.
Los Angeles MEHKO Program Guide
Permit requirements, operational limits, prohibited food items, and tax obligations for Microenterprise Home Kitchen Operations in Los Angeles County.
Disclaimer: This guide is general information, not tax advice for your specific situation. Tax law changes, and how a rule applies depends on your facts. Reading this page does not create a client relationship with Arc & Ledger LLC. Before acting on anything here, confirm how it applies to your circumstances with a qualified tax professional.